Repair or Replace
Work out when it makes sense to move on.
Separate a repair bill from a pattern of trouble
Start with a diagnosis, not the frustration
A breakdown is inconvenient, and a large estimate can make replacing the vehicle feel like the only reasonable response. But one repair does not necessarily mean the vehicle has reached the end of its useful life. This tool considers age, repair cost relative to current value, the frequency of recent repairs and how much you depend on the vehicle. It helps organise the decision after you have a credible diagnosis; it cannot diagnose the fault itself.
Compare the right numbers
Use the vehicle’s realistic current resale value when choosing the repair-cost band. The original purchase price and the amount already spent are not what a replacement decision is about today. A repair exceeding roughly forty percent of current value gets a strong replacement weight, but that is a planning heuristic rather than a mechanical rule. Compare the repair with the extra cash needed to obtain a genuinely better replacement, including registration, insurance, finance charges and any immediate work on a used replacement.
Frequency and downtime change the answer
A young vehicle with one contained issue generally scores towards repair. Several unrelated failures in the last year make future downtime less predictable and push the recommendation towards reviewing replacement. Normal servicing, tyres and routine consumables should not be counted as breakdowns. If the vehicle is essential to your work or family responsibilities, the cost of alternate transport and missed commitments belongs in the decision. Conversely, having a reliable alternative can make a carefully planned repair easier to absorb.
Make the final check outside the calculator
Ask the mechanic what the quoted work fixes, what it does not fix and whether other major components are nearing replacement. A second written estimate is especially useful for expensive work. Brakes, steering, structural damage and overheating deserve immediate professional attention; do not keep driving an unsafe vehicle while weighing costs. Local registration, fitness or vehicle-age restrictions can also limit remaining usable life and must be checked separately. Sentimental value is real and may justify spending more than the arithmetic suggests, provided you can afford it and the vehicle can be made safe. If replacing remains attractive, compare new versus used and stress-test the monthly budget before acting.
A few useful answers.
Is forty percent a hard cut-off?
No. It is a heuristic that increases the replacement score. Diagnosis, replacement cost and remaining condition still matter.
Should routine servicing count as a repair?
No. Count unexpected faults rather than planned services or ordinary consumable replacement.
What about sentimental value?
It is a valid reason to value the vehicle differently. The tool cannot price that attachment or establish that a repair is safe.